Culture and Cultural Analysis as Experimental Systems
Link to relevant CA essay lists: Science and Technology Studies (STS), Culture/Theory
MIT Professor of Anthropology and Science and Technology Studies Michael Fischer has published an essay in the current issue of Cultural Anthropology that provides new perspective on the history of the concept of "culture," emphasizing how cultural analysis has been linked to social reform in different periods.
Titled "Culture and Cultural Analysis as Experimental Systems," the essay traces the growth of cultural analysis from the nineteenth century through the present, showing how the concept of culture has evolved and enabled cultural analysis to operate as an "experimental system" that both codifies knowledge, and creates fundamentally new insight. In casting cultural analysis as an "experimental system," Fischer suggests similarities between cultural analysis and the natural sciences, highlighting how both create new knowledge though structured engagements between established theory and empirical data that cannot be sufficiently explained in terms of such theory.
Fischer also highlights the importance of recognizing "culture" as an analytic tool rather than as a variable that can be blamed for social problems, or used to explain "the clash of civilizations." "Culture," Fischer argues, is "where meaning is woven and renewed," by professional cultural analysts as well as by the people they study. The continuing challenge of cultural analysis, Fischer argues, "is to develop translation and mediation tools for helping make visible differences of interests, access, power, needs, desires, and philosophical perspective. In particular, as we begin to face new kinds of ethical dilemmas stemming from developments in biotechnologies, expansive information and image databases, and ecological interactions, we are challenged to develop differentiated cultural analyses that can help articulate new social institutions for an evolving civil society."
Over the last twenty years, Cultural Anthropology has published a number of essays that historicize and critically engage the culture concept. See, for example, Akhil Gupta and James Ferguson's "Beyond "Culture": Space, Identity, and the Politics of Difference" (1992), Anna Tsing's "From the Margins" (1994), Robert Brightman's "Forget Culture: Replacement, Transcendence, Relexification" (1995), and Richard Handler's "Raymond Williams, George Stocking, and Fin-de-Siècle U.S. Anthropology" (1998). For a list of essays in Cultural Anthropology on the theory and practice of cultural analysis, see http://culanth.org/?q=node/24.
Cultural Anthropology essays can be accessed electronically through AnthroSource, http://www.anthrosource.net/, which is available through most research libraries and to all members of the American Anthropological Association. Journalists may request PDFs from Cultural Anthropology's editorial office: email@example.com.
AUTHOR'S WEBPAGE: Michael Fischer